The reddish colour of birria comes from the red-chilli sauce used to cook and serve it. The chilli blend and the way that sauce is prepared help explain differences between versions.
Where the red colour comes from
Red chillies are blended into the cooking sauce rather than added only as a garnish. A useful example is Rick Bayless’s recipe for red-chile birria tacos, which uses guajillo chillies in the marinade. Its listed ingredients do not require achiote or a three-chilli combination. This is an attributed example, not La Toxica’s recipe.
- Chillies: the guajillo sauce supplies the red-chile component in this example.
- Achiote: it is not included in this example; its presence cannot be assumed from the colour alone.
- Other ingredients: tomatoes are not listed in this example either, so they are not a universal requirement for red birria.
How the sauce reaches the meat
The chillies are toasted, softened in water and blended with the seasonings. The marinade is added to the meat for braising. This connects the red-chile base with the cooking liquid rather than relying on a separate colouring step.
Why the broth and tortillas also look red
The example separates the fat from the braising liquid and reduces the broth before serving. The tortillas are coated with the reserved fat on the griddle. That explains how the chilli-based preparation contributes to the appearance of both the meat and its accompaniments.
For a useful comparison between two batches, note their chilli ingredients and how the sauce and broth were prepared. A particular shade does not prove regional origin, authenticity or safe cooking.